How can Disability Services teams protect student access when faculty push back on AI?

As faculty tighten AI policies, approved accommodations are getting caught in the crossfire. In a recent Genio webinar, three Disability Services leaders were asked what is working, and how they are meeting challenges head-on.
Clock 3 min read Calendar Published: 19 Nov 2026
Author
A laptop with a padlock and key, and a stamped piece of paper

Key takeaways:

  • Keep the focus on the need: An AI tool request becomes an accommodation when it addresses a specific disability-related barrier, not when it only saves time.
  • AI speeds up the work, humans still check it: AI is cutting the time it takes to write alt text for STEM exams, but every description still gets human review.
  • AI-proof exams can block access: Paper exams and lockdown browsers can shut out screen readers, dictation and spell check unless Disability Services plans ahead.
  • Strict syllabus language has a hidden cost: Some students stop using their approved assistive technology because they fear being judged or standing out.
  • Show faculty, don't just tell them: A live demo and clear privacy safeguards resolve more pushback than any policy document.

AI is changing how faculty teach and assess, and Disability and Accessibility Services teams are seeing the effects first. Lecture recording, laptops and assistive technology used as disability accommodations are all under fresh scrutiny.

In a recent Genio webinar, we were joined by Vicky Codas, Assistant Director, Disability Support & Assistive Technology at American University; Vineeta Ram, Assistant Director, DSS & Access Technology at Colorado School of Mines; and Charlotte Schiff-Norton, Accessible & Assistive Technology Specialist at the UC Davis Student Disability Center.

Here is what they shared about faculty AI policies, exam accommodations and how to keep student access protected heading into 2027.

How is AI changing the work of Disability Services teams?

AI is already saving Disability Services teams time. Writing alt text for graphs and charts in STEM exams used to be slow, painstaking work. Now teams can draft it with AI and proofread the result.

Assistive study tools are changing too. Many now let students quiz themselves on their own notes, and the panel described these tools as closed, working only from the student's material rather than the open web.

But, the guardrails stay the same. Any tool that handles student information needs university security approval, and a person always reviews the output. 

Is an AI tool request an accommodation or a productivity preference?

Whether an AI tool request is an accommodation or a productivity preference depends on the need it addresses.

Vicky calls this line one of the biggest conversations on her team, and Vineeta says it keeps coming up at Colorado School of Mines and with colleagues elsewhere.

In practice, there is no standard answer yet. Decisions happen case by case, often in conversation with instructors about their learning objectives.

How are AI policies changing exams for students with accommodations?

It depends on the discipline. Some instructors are building AI into assignments, for example allowing it for an outline but not the final product.

Others are going back to paper, in-person testing and lockdown browsers.

That second group creates new barriers. Not every lockdown browser works with a screen reader, and an exam with no internet access can remove a spell check accommodation.

The answer is preparation: checking which text to speech and dictation tools work inside each platform, and proctoring closely when a student needs internet access.

Why are some students avoiding their approved assistive technology?

Strict "no AI" or "no laptops" language in a syllabus can make students afraid to use the tools they are entitled to.

"They're afraid their professor is going to judge them differently. They want to meld in with their peers. They don't want to stick out." 
Charlotte Schiff-Norton, UC Davis

Charlotte has seen students with recording accommodations go back to smart pens and recorders rather than open a laptop in class. The accommodation exists on paper, but the student is not using it.

How can Disability Services handle faculty pushback over AI?

Most pushback centers on lecture recording and laptops in class. Across all three campuses, the approach is the same. Be transparent, and start from the instructor's concern.

“It's important to be transparent and understand where the instructor is coming from.” 
Vineeta Ram, Colorado School of Mines

In practice, that means demoing the technology, sharing its privacy safeguards and showing that the tool is vetted by the university.

Students sign agreements not to share recordings, and misuse can cost them the accommodation.

When a professor still objects, the conversation shifts to what alternative would meet the same need, which often opens a productive discussion about Universal Design for Learning (UDL).

What will change for AI and accessibility in 2027?

The panel expects more questions, but less fear.

Teams will grow more comfortable even as the pace of change stays fast, and some classes will likely ban laptops, pushing DSS teams to find creative ways to meet accommodation needs.

There is also a reframe worth sharing with faculty.

Navigation, image description and many other everyday access tools have used AI for years. As Vicky, who is totally blind, put it, people just were not calling it AI.

How does Genio Notes support Disability Services teams?

Genio Notes gives students with accommodations a secure way to record, caption and organize class content while building their own notes.

We do not use any captured data, including class content or notes, to train our AI models. Our AI Hub and Faculty FAQs are on-hand to answer the questions faculty ask most.

Want to see how you can incorporate Genio Notes into your institution's accommodations? 

Book a free demo today
Time for a simpler, smarter note taking accommodation?

Time for a simpler, smarter note taking accommodation?

Genio Notes is the online note taking tool that makes compliance simple, reduces cost and admin burden, and improves student outcomes.
Learn More